![]()
Book Blogger Confessions is a biweekly meme hosted by For What It’s Worth and Tiger’s All Consuming Media
July16th: What do we owe publishers and authors? If we accept ARC’s do we “owe” anything to them or just an honest review to our followers? As book bloggers are we obligated to do more than just review books? Post covers – participate in book tours – host guest posts – promote authors?
What do we owe publishers and authors? If we accept ARC’s do we “owe” anything to them or just an honest review to our followers?
I think we owe a couple of things to the publishers/publicists and authors that we work with. First and foremost we owe an honest review of the book provided to us. We owe that to our readers as well, and I’ve said it before…the reviews we write should be written for the reader not the author or the publisher. We don’t write critical/analytical reviews here. There are “professionals” who do that…although I seem to disagree a lot with those reviews.
What we write here are our thoughts and feelings on the book. I think that’s what our readers are looking for as well. In the majority of my own reviews I also like to include a line or note to the author. If a review happens to be a “good” review, and the author and/or publisher wants to feature it on their site, on twitter, Facebook, etc. then I’m totally cool with that. In fact, I’m delighted when that happens.
Whenever we receive ARCs or ebooks for review I normally remind whoever is sending it to me that if we read it and it doesn’t rate at least a three then it won’t get a review on Bookish. Also, unless it’s for a specific release date or a blog tour I don’t make promises as to when the book will be reviewed.
As book bloggers are we obligated to do more than just review books? Post covers – participate in book tours – host guest posts – promote authors?
I don’t think we’re obligated to do any of those things, but my question would be…why wouldn’t you want to? I wouldn’t do them if I didn’t like the book, but I like to participate in all of those things not only to spotlight and support the authors and their books that I love, but I think my readers enjoy all those things as well. I know for sure that anytime I’ve hosted guest posts they’re very popular.
As far as promoting authors? If I love the books they’ve written I want the whole world to know about it and to read them. If I happen to also like the author? Even better as far as I’m concerned. If we’re being honest aren’t we more apt to be enthusiastically supportive long after we’ve reviewed a book if we feel we have some sort of connection? Maybe that’s just me.
I’m going to be less than humble right here and say that I think I’m pretty damn creative at coming up with different kinds of posts to keep an author, and their book(s) on people’s minds. So yeah…chat me up on a personal level. I know that some book bloggers have a “no author fraternization” policy and if that works for them then so be it. Btw, I have an upcoming Observations post that will discuss this more fully as well as the reverse of this question…do publishers/authors owe book bloggers anything.
Alright peeps…my question to you is this? Am I right in thinking you guys love seeing more than reviews here? Do you like the guest posts? Interviews? Cover reveals? Etc.?
Tamie Xo
Absolutely! I love coming to your blog (for various reasons!) not only for the book reviews but for all the added extras and perks. And meeting all the fellow ‘bookish’ followers and authors is one of my favorite parts!
Thank you!
It’s helpful to know that we’re doing the kinds of posts you want to see. <3
I love books and everything about them!! I also love that you do so much more than just review them. And um, the pics/photos here are kind of awesome and HAWT.
There will be more awesome and hawt pics/photos coming soon
I love the variety that you have here. Plus, you are awesome.
Thanks bb! I think you’re awesome too. (((((hugs)))))
I love all the extras you provide on your blog, in addition to your thoughtful and honest reviews. And where else can you get Wordless Wednesday!!! <3
Speaking of Wordless Wednesday…I haven’t abandoned them. I’ll have one next week for sure
I was relieved to see that you simply don’t post reviews for books that you don’t like…mainly because that’s how I approach leaving comments and scores on places like Goodreads and Amazon. I can’t help thinking that someone else might enjoy a book that didn’t do anything for me, and I don’t want to put them off if. I’m just a reader (a really fanatic one), not a blogger, so I don’t have the breadth of awareness that someone who’s been reading the genre for several years has. Maybe when I’m better versed, I’ll be more inclined to share unfavorable criticism. In the meantime, if I can’t find reviews by my favorite bloggers of books I’m thinking about buying…I just take a pass.
Thanks…I decided on the policy because I don’t like to read negative reviews myself.
I’d much rather spend time sharing what I love rather than what I don’t.